Do rattles in lures help or hurt for pike?
Honestly: it is situational and the evidence is thin either way. In dark or weedy water a rattle adds one more locating cue and probably helps a pike home in; in clear, calm, hard-fished water, some anglers are convinced silent baits draw more strikes from conditioned fish, and there is enough pattern to respect that. Treat rattles like any other variable — an option to rotate through, not a rule — and remember that a pike's low-frequency hearing means a soft thump matters more than a high-pitched shake.
The full story
This answer is one piece of a longer lesson — setups, diagrams and the reasoning behind it.
More questions about Hearing & Inner Ear
Same topic, other species
- Does a trolling motor spook crappie? — Crappie
- Can bass hear my trolling motor or me moving around the boat? — Largemouth Bass
- Do rattles help or hurt on muskie baits? — Muskellunge (Muskie)
- Does noise matter more over hard bottom? — Yellow Perch
- How much does wading noise spook trout? — Trout (Rainbow · Brook · Lake)
- Does boat noise or an ice auger spook walleye? — Walleye